What to wear to a broadway show: There are no rules. These days, you can wear whatever you want to a broadway show. Dressing up is a nice way to turn a night at the theater. Canvas shoes with knee cut pants give the edge in the outfit. Always carry a jacket, coat, or a shawl to new york broadway shows. Navy coat in winter cozy and classy at the same time. Velvet pants are foolproof when putting together your show attire. Broadway doesn’t have a specific dress code (anymore). Some people go in jeans and others make a special night of it and dress up.